And the head of Instagram just admitted it publicly.
Adam Mosseri's biggest product mistake at Instagram: the first version of Reels was built on top of Stories.
The logic made sense at the time:
- Stories were growing faster than anything else in the app
- Adding Reels inside Stories meant no new surface, no cluttered UI
- Classic product thinking – extend what's already working
Here's what actually happened:
- Stories have a low read-through rate – most people don't finish them
- There are too many Stories to consume – Reels got buried
- Content disappeared after 24 hours – no discovery, no recommendations loop
- The format had no dedicated space to surface new creators
Result: most Reels were never seen by anyone.
Mosseri's take: if the summer 2020 version of Reels had launched in summer 2019, TikTok would still be big – but not as big as it is now. The pandemic hit, people had time at home, phones were on with sound, and Instagram was out of position.
The real lesson here isn't about Reels vs TikTok.
It's that protecting product simplicity can become a strategic mistake when a new mechanic requires its own architecture.
Sometimes the right call is adding a new surface – even if it feels like clutter.
Have you ever seen a product team avoid the right solution because it felt "too big" to build?
Want a stronger data analyst role or a raise? Grab the FREE Product Analyst Playbook and get the exact roadmap to your next offer.


